NSW ID card a 'gift to terrorists'

The Photo Card Bill 2004, which passed through the New South Wales Legislative Assembly today, has been described as a "gift to organised criminals, terrorists, and other people intent on doing harm" by the Australian Privacy Foundation.

"This Bill has seen almost no debate, and no public consultation -- yet it introduces the most fundamental attack on our personal freedom since the failed 'Australia Card' proposal of the 1980s," said Anna Johnston, chairperson of the APF.

Labor state MP and parliamentary secretary Tony Stewart first introduced the bill last December with the intent to authorise the Roads and Traffic Authority (RTA) to introduce a state photo card for those who had no driver's licence, proof of age card, or other forms of identification such as a passport or photo birth card.

"Many people often have a need to produce some form of personal identification in order to secure goods and services. Businesses and government agencies also rely on a photo identification document to provide assurance that the person that they are dealing with is who they say they are. The NSW Government has been approached by numerous community groups asking for a NSW photo card," he previously said.

On behalf of then Roads Minister Carl Scully -- who first drafted the Bill -- Stewart denied that the NSW photo card was another 'Australia Card'.

"The card will be purely voluntary and will help those in the community who have a need for a photo card but cannot have one because they do not fit the criteria for other photo identification," Stewart said during the Bill's second reading.

However, APF's Johnston said the Bill was the "worst kind of Big Brother proposal" because it "places no limits on how much information the RTA can collect about people, and few limits on who can access the data". Additionally, she believes the centralised database required to realise the proposal is likely to increase the risk of identity theft and fraud.

"They will be able to track when you book a flight, borrow a video, post a gift overseas, or go to the pub. The Commonwealth Government has recognised the risks of centralising vast amounts of personal data -- it means only one database to hack into, or one clerk at the RTA to bribe," said Johnston.

"If the Coalition, minor parties and independents don't force amendments to this Bill, we will soon be seeing an Australia Card for NSW," she added.

Like this article? Click below to send it to your mobile for free!

Advertisement

Talkback 3 comments

  1. All they are trying to is create a Driver's License that doesn't allow you to drive a car or have to take a test to get the ID. What's the problem with that? Becuase the RTA doesn't monitor all my transactions that I make when I have to produce my Driver' Anonymous -- 07/04/05

    All they are trying to is create a Driver's License that doesn't allow you to drive a car or have to take a test to get the ID. What's the problem with that? Becuase the RTA doesn't monitor all my transactions that I make when I have to produce my Driver's License?

  2. The problem is that this card (like the australia card) offers only very limited restrictions on the data that can be ****ociated to the card, and that there aren't currently enough safeguards to ensure that only those with legitimate reasons can view thi Anonymous -- 07/04/05

    The problem is that this card (like the australia card) offers only very limited restrictions on the data that can be ****ociated to the card, and that there aren't currently enough safeguards to ensure that only those with legitimate reasons can view this data.
    I don't want any tom dick or harry to have access to potentialy personal information.

  3. This is a ridiculous argument to mount against a very practical way for people to be able to prove who they are. Linking such a card to increased terrorism, doesn't add up if the card will give the ability to track an individual's movement, an abili Anonymous -- 08/04/05

    This is a ridiculous argument to mount against a very practical way for people to be able to prove who they are.
    Linking such a card to increased terrorism, doesn't add up if the card will give the ability to track an individual's movement, an ability by the way that already exists everytime you use your credit card, or are caught on the huge number of camera's that we all smile for every day.
    Keeping even the simplest databases nowadays is usually done on multiple computers with high level encryption.
    If someone wants to go to the trouble of tracking my life I suggest they might need to get one of their own. Please pollies reign in the paranoia and let's extend to others the ability to be able to meet the ID requirements, so many of us take for granted with our Drivers Licence

Add your opinion


Latest Videos

ZDNet's CIO Vision Series

Video | Optus CIO Lawrie Turner

In this exclusive video interview, Optus chief information officer Lawrie Turner speaks to ZDNet.com.au about being the IT head for Australia's number two telco.

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

  • David Braue Telstra's BT coat doesn't fit
    The vision of the future BT portrayed this week at an Australian conference was so far removed from how Telstra's David Quilty has described the British telco that I wonder if they were talking about the same UK.
  • Array Australian security: the lucky country
    Does anyone seriously believe that Australian businesses and government agencies manage security any better than the US or UK?
  • Array Storage infrastructure on the tender track
    For a large-scale storage project, it's not uncommon to go out to tender for the best deal — but when was the last time you had to put together a tender for a document management room?
  • More blogs »

Tags

Back to top

Featured